Truth in advertising: this comparison features the previous generations of Rogue and Forester, which is ideal if you're comparing used cars. See comparisons with the current generations.
 


 
Nissan Rogue SV AWD
 
Subaru Forester Premium AWD
 






Planet's Executive Summary
Both were entirely redesigned for the 2014 model year.  Forester was refreshed for 2017. They are built on car platforms (rather than truck frames) so both offer compliant handling with light off-road capability.  Nissan offers third row seating, which is unique in this compact crossover segment (aft seats are best used in a pinch for small kids).  Forester has racked up so many awards (from Motor Trend's Sport Utility of the Year to IIHS Top Safety Pick Plus and many in between) that Subaru's trophy shelves are sagging. 







Similar sizes, but Rogue is slightly larger in every dimension:

  • Rogue is an inch and a half wider.
  • Rogue is an inch and a half longer.
  • Rogue is one inch taller.






Differences
Rogue
 Forester






All Wheel Drive Systems
Rogue began life as front wheel drive Sentra, and then Nissan bolted on hardware to power the rear wheels.  Forester was engineered from the ground up with Subaru's legendary all wheel drive system.





















Ground clearance
The extra inch makes a big difference in deep snow, which can hang you up by lifting all four wheels off the ground.












7.4 inches







8.7 inches


Passenger Volume

 100 Cubic Feet

103 cubic feet





Cargo Space

Rogue has more cargo space, especially with seats up.  Forester is more squared off so it swallows up your full sized golden retriever. Dog costs extra.



















  70 cubic feet (seats down)
 39 cubic feet (seats up)

 












68 cubic feet (seats down)
31 cubic feet (seats up)

Third Row Seating
For an extra $826, Nissan offers the only third row seating in this segment.  Not much room, but enough in a pinch for small kids.  Unfortunately, you lose the spare tire, requiring run flat tires which are approximately double the replacement cost of regular tires.  Also, your kids are in the crumple zone. 
















   







 
Not available
on Forester.















Standard Engine and acceleration





















2.5 liter in-line
four cylinder
with
170 horsepower

0-60mph:  8.6 seconds

2.5 liter four cylinder
Boxer engine

with 170 horsepower


0-60mph:  8.5 seconds




Fuel Economy
Both use leading edge transmissions for great
gas mileage.







Continuously variable
 auto transmission

24 city, 32 hwy



Lineartronic Continuously variable auto transmission

26 city, 32 hwy













Need some extra go-go?







 










no
power
upgrade
available








2.0 liter turbocharged
four cylinder with
continuously variable
automatic transmission.

250 horsepower.


23 city, 28 highway.


0-60 mph 6.1 seconds

Towing Capacity

You won't be towing your yacht with either vehicle, but both accommodate a small trailer.  Both require optional hitches.






1,000 pounds





1,500 pounds






Outward Visibility

Rogue's styling is handsome, like a baby Pathfinder.  Rear windows taper, where Forester has glass.  Forester was recognized as the #1 vehicle for visibility of any car on the road!  Those big rear windows help a lot. 













  
 


 
 


 


Panoramic Power
Moonroof

Forester uses one piece of solid glass for the open-air feeling of a convertible. 















 
 




 










Price
Comparably equipped, Forester is considerably less expensive, and includes heated seats/mirrors/wipers too.












$27,760

















$26,145

Forester models
and prices







Safety
Forester goes one better on Insurance Institute for Highway Safety rankings, earning "Top Safety Pick PLUS." 















Rogue test results








 Forester test results
 



Purchase and Ownership Experience

You can buy a new Subaru at Planet, but not a new Nissan.


 









Search our inventory for your Forester:


    

...Or look at our nice Nissan trades...







Exclusive Planet Subaru Benefit: The Planet Passport Program




 








 
 






 





People from Boston, Watertown, Braintree, Natick, and the North Shore trust Planet for great deals and useful info like this comparison between the Subaru Forester and the Nissan Rogue.